Italian Tomato and Bread Soup (Pappa Al Pomodoro) Recipe



Make method for this Italian Tomato and Bread Soup! Wealthy flavors of San Marzano tomatoes, recent basil, thinly sliced garlic, silky olive oil swirls, and bread cubes all through.

Deep, unimpeded, candy tomato taste with swirls of garlic and wealthy velvety olive oil, vibrant recent basil and, hearken to this, your hunky crusty bread dips are already included! Make method for tomato and bread soup also referred to as pappa al pomodoro.

Pappa al pomodoro hails from the Tuscany area of Italy and is particularly common and fiercely claimed in Florence and Siena. It primarily interprets to “tomato mush” and relying on the place you have got it and who’s making it, it could possibly vary in texture from extra of a porridge to a barely thinner soup or stew consistency like we’ve got right here. However any method you have got it, it’s undoubtedly all of the yum. Simply, all of it.

This recipe is from Marika Contaldo Seguso, an Italian cookbook creator, and you could find her authentic pappa al pomodoro recipe in Milk Street.

In This Submit: All the pieces You Want For Tomato and Bread Soup

Want To Watch As an alternative Of Learn?

Components We’re Working with For This Soup

The ingredient listing for tomato and bread soup like that is at all times fantastically quick, every taste standing by itself. Right here’s what you’ll want for this model:

  • canned entire peeled San Marzano tomatoes
  • dried or stale bread
  • additional virgin olive oil
  • garlic
  • recent basil
  • vegetable/rooster broth

As a result of there are so few parts, you actually need to use prime quality elements to achieve peak taste. San Marzanos are scrumptious, fruit, and fewer acidic than different tomatoes. You’ll need actually good additional virgin olive oil each for the soup and for the silky drizzles on prime for serving. Contemporary basil versus dried right here. And an excellent crusty white bread will do the trick.

Ingredients laid out for pappa al pomodoro

Let’s Make Pappa Al Pomodoro (Tomato and Bread Soup)

As talked about, this recipe is a little bit thinner than a extra conventional pappa al pomodoro however by all means, if you wish to thicken it up, you’ll be able to alter the broth/bread ratio (or omit broth altogether and simply let the tomatoes function the liquid) till it’s so thick your spoon stands up! Which, relying on the place you might be, may be the mark of a very divine pappa in Italy. You may additionally skinny it out if that’s extra pleasing! Our texture candy spot was often a one cup of broth per ciabatta roll ratio.

Right here’s how we did this one:

  1. Tomatoes. Get your palms in there and crush!
  2. Garlic & Olive Oil. Sauté garlic in oil till aromatic after which add your crushed tomatoes and let simmer for a bit. Then add your broth & basil and preserve simmering.
  3. Bread. Add dried bread to the tomato/broth combination and simmer till the bread is delicate. Then you should utilize a potato masher or whisk to maintain breaking it down.
  4. Serve. We served this with additional olive oil drizzles, extra recent basil, and okay additionally some Parm, yum!

What Sort Of Bread To Use Right here

Italian tomato and bread soup is definitely born of a time the place it was the worst potential crime to let a single little bit of bread go to waste (nonetheless feels correct…we ❤️ bread), even when it’s a stale one. So historically, it’s made with very stale Tuscan bread, ideally neglected for a number of days. Tuscan bread particularly is made with out salt (which dates again to the twelfth century when commerce strains had been minimize off to Florence making salt tremendous costly!) and that meant the bread went stale moderately rapidly. Thus, this soup, and different scrumptious issues like panzanella salad, was a approach to flip stale bread right into a dream of a dish.

Traditionalists say a no-salt Tuscan bread is one of the best right here, however that’s onerous to seek out exterior of Tuscany, so any crusty rustic white bread would do like:

  • ciabatta (we used the rolls, minimize up and dried out)
  • boule
  • any country-style bread
  • every other rustic Italian or French bread

Your Bread – The Drier, The Higher!

When you haven’t thought forward and left your bread out (or simply occurred to neglect you had bread and it acquired stale all by itself! Go you! That’s not an oops, that’s a yay this time!), you’ll be able to minimize up your bread and toast it within the oven to dry it out.

  • Minimize bread into slices/cubes or tear it up & unfold on a sheet pan
  • 450 diploma oven for about 5-7 minutes till it’s dry (not browned), tossing halfway

However once more, if on a Monday you’re considering, “Man, I’d love some tomato bread soup on Wednesday”, toss that loaf on the counter, good friend, and simply completely neglect about it!

Olive oil being poured into tomato and bread soup

How To Choose Out The Finest Tomatoes For Soup

If you end up with a glut of sun-ripened summer season tomatoes in your palms, THIS IS YOUR MOMENT. All that recent, unfussed, candy tomato taste is strictly what you need for this, so it’s undoubtedly not the time for any hothouse, low season tomatoes.

When you’re utilizing recent tomatoes:

  • Roma tomatoes are an important possibility, however actually any tremendous ripe, candy tomato would do
  • Peel them by scoring with a knife, then giving them a drop in boiling water for a bit, and they need to peel simply (tomato skins aren’t actually a enjoyable soup texture shock)

However if you happen to’re like us, you’ll need this soup straightforward and also you’ll need this year-round and by chance you’ll be able to have it! Thanks to essentially good canned or jarred tomatoes. Yay for simplicity! That’s how we do.

When you’re utilizing canned tomatoes (like us!), some issues to think about:

  • San Marzano tomatoes are tops (very prime quality, grown in Italy, decrease acidity)
  • entire peeled tomatoes (vs. diced/crushed) are greatest for optimum style and texture

Crushing Tomatoes By Hand

Whether or not you might be utilizing recent or canned, you’re going to need to crush these entire peeled tomatoes BY HAND. Sure, that’s proper. Get in there. Not solely is it a type of delightfully squashy sensory expertise, it actually will provide you with one of the best texture. Some chunks of various dimension and sufficient delicate vibrant crimson liquid.

Whenever you mix your tomatoes, they flip type of orangish as soon as the air is buzzed into them so if you wish to protect that hyper-fresh, vibrant crimson, completely textured, fun-to-squeeze, chunky tomato goodness? Roll your sleeves up, mates, and get at it.

(Certain, you may pop them in a plastic baggie first and squish from there however the place’s the enjoyable in that?!)

Variations On This Tomato and Bread Soup

Although you would possibly get a little bit side-eye from any Tuscan, particularly round Florence and Siena, for including something however basil, garlic, tomatoes, bread, and olive oil to this soup, there are actually methods you’ll be able to mess around with it! We added Parmesan to ours and it was scrumptious.

However if you happen to’re already breaking soup legal guidelines, listed below are another issues to attempt:

  • hefty shakes of crushed crimson peppers for spice
  • some diced onion or carrot/onion/celery
  • oregano
  • a dollop of ricotta

Tuscan households might most likely struggle all day about their pappa recipes. To onion or to not onion, broth or sizzling water or “how dare you”…the listing might go on! The simplicity of this dish and its elements is basically what makes it shine although, so don’t be shy to let her stand as she is.

When you’re a rule-follower and don’t need to mess with soup legal guidelines, you’ll be able to preserve the soup easy after which simply accompany it with another lovelies like:

You’ve gotten choices! However you even have swizzles upon swizzles of wealthy olive oil and peppery torn basil and deep tomato taste that already tastes like bread dips. You actually are set.

Superbly easy, recent, wealthy, and scrumptious. You can not go flawed with this soup.

Tomato and bread soup in a bowl with fresh basil and parmesan

Italian Tomato and Bread Soup: Regularly Requested Questions

How ought to I retailer or serve leftovers of this soup?

This soup will do okay as leftovers within the fridge for 1 day. It might nonetheless be eaten, loved, and never too soggy. When you’re delicate to texture, make the tomato base and add the bread about 10 minutes earlier than serving the soup.

Do you suggest recent or dried herbs for this soup?

Contemporary is the way in which to go right here, if you could find them within the retailer.

How can I make this soup vegan?

Simply use a vegan Parm cheese, if you happen to plan so as to add that in, and use veggie broth.


clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfb fb iconprint print iconsquares squares iconcoronary heart coronary heart iconcoronary heart stable coronary heart stable icon


Make method for this Italian Tomato and Bread Soup! Wealthy flavors of San Marzano tomatoes, recent basil, thinly sliced garlic, silky olive oil swirls, and bread cubes all through. 

  • 3 tablespoons additional virgin olive oil
  • 3 cloves garlic, smashed or thinly sliced
  • one 28-ounce can entire peeled San Marzano tomatoes
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt
  • Freshly floor black pepper to style
  • 4 cups vegetable or rooster broth
  • 1/4 cup packed recent basil, chopped or torn
  • 23 cups dry bread, torn or minimize into cubes (see notes)

  1. Warmth the olive oil in a big pot over medium warmth. Add the garlic; sauté for 1 minute.
  2. In a separate bowl, crush tomatoes by hand. Add them into the pot. Add salt and pepper. Partially cowl and simmer over medium warmth for about ten minutes.
  3. Add the broth and basil; deliver again to a simmer for an additional ten minutes.
  4. Add the bread cubes; simmer for an additional ten minutes till the bread is delicate. You should use a potato masher to additional break down the bread to your required texture. 
  5. Serve with Parmesan cheese, additional olive oil, and extra recent basil! Simplicity and prime notch elements… it’s simply gorgeous.


For the bread, I’ve been utilizing ciabatta take-and-bake rolls as a result of I so hardly ever have a loaf of dry bread sitting round! I toast them within the oven till they’re fairly crunchy and dry, after which I pull them aside into small chunks so as to add to the soup. My rule of thumb is about 1 cup of broth per 1 roll. So 4 rolls = 4 cups broth, 5 rolls = 5 cups broth, and so forth. Clearly rising the ratio of bread to broth will make the soup thicker, and vice versa! Make it what you need! ❤️

  • Prep Time: 10 minutes
  • Cook dinner Time: half-hour
  • Class: Soup
  • Methodology: Stovetop
  • Delicacies: Italian-Impressed

Key phrases: tomato and bread soup, pappa al pomodoro, italian soup

Recipe Card powered by Tasty Recipes logo

Extra Contemporary Tomato Recipes We Love


Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here