Welcome to Best of the Test, a totally examined, expertly vetted, solely semi-serious product advice collection. Be a part of us as we sleep with a dozen completely different mattress sheets, make gallons of ice, air fry all of the wings, and extra in pursuit of the easiest issues to purchase.
I’m the kind of one who reaches for an ice-cold drink even in the course of winter. No critically, regardless of the climate, I’ve at all times acquired one thing chilly in my fingers—water, espresso, candy tea, matcha. Now that temps are rising and out of doors entertaining is hitting its peak, having a full stash of ice prepared to relax a number of drinks without delay is extra of vital than a nice-to-have.
Only one downside…okay, two: 1) My fridge doesn’t have a built-in ice maker, and a pair of) my freezer is usually too packed to stack greater than two ice trays (and precariously, at that). Driving to the closest grocery retailer or gasoline station for bagged ice is inconvenient at greatest, and making an attempt to freeze just a few trays of ice and retailer the cubes in a bucket within the freezer (rinse and repeat) earlier than friends come over feels like a nightmare.
So when the time to check countertop ice makers got here round, you wager I used to be stone-cold prepared.
How we examined the perfect ice machines
To find out which ice machines to check, I spent hours doing market analysis that concerned studying what different business people take into account to be the perfect, filtering via glad (and unhappy) buyer evaluations, and looking via high sellers at our neighborhood’s favourite on-line shops. Just like my experience with insulated water bottles, there have been so. many. ice makers in the marketplace—and admittedly, all of them sounded the identical.
So I developed a set of testing parameters—the machines needed to: be offered in a number of big-box shops like Amazon and The Home Depot for ease of procuring, be straightforward to arrange and clear, underneath 18 inches in peak (the usual peak between kitchen counters and cupboards), produce not less than 9 items of bullet ice per cycle (the market common for bullet ice makers), produce not less than 24 kilos of ice in 24 hours (the typical of a few dozen completely different fashions I’d thought of), and have not less than a one-year guarantee on components.
I examined 5 standard ice machines for about three weeks, operating each across the clock and placing them via a collection of stress exams and real-life conditions. I additionally spoke with our drinks knowledgeable and Resident John deBary, in addition to CEO and co-owner of Appliances Connection Albert Fouerti, about ice machine cleansing, upkeep, and extra.
Right here’s how we examined and evaluated the perfect ice machines:
Setup: I arrange every machine in my pantry based on the producers’ directions. Whereas some machines wanted simply an outlet and water to begin making ice, others have been a bit extra concerned, requiring connecting tubes to a separate water reservoir or operating a cleansing cycle earlier than utilizing.
Cleansing: After every week of testing, I adopted the producers’ directions on cleansing the inside or operating the self-cleaning cycle with vinegar.
Ice manufacturing: Variables like ambient temperature, water stage, and site of the machine all play a task in how rapidly ice is made, so measuring ice manufacturing was difficult. It will even be inefficient (and tiresome!) to weigh each single batch of ice every machine revamped a 24-hour interval to find out how a lot ice was produced. As an alternative, I timed how lengthy every machine took to make one batch of ice, weighed every batch, after which did the maths to see how a lot ice would theoretically be made in 24 hours in my particular setting—utilizing chilly water from the faucet, with the water crammed to the max line, and in a room about 74°F with none direct lights hitting the machines.
Every machine was off its marketed manufacturing by a pound or two, which is negligible. For a extra helpful gauge of ice manufacturing, every batch made 9 items of bullet ice and roughly crammed up half a 12-ounce glass.
Ice high quality: Every bullet ice maker had the choice of small and huge ice sizes, so I made a number of batches of every measurement and in contrast the standard of ice. Whereas the small bullet ice was teeny and absurdly cute, I like to recommend setting your ice machine to make the massive measurement—the small ice melted too rapidly, so that you’d wind up with watery ice earlier than you may even chill your drink. However, the nugget ice machines I examined didn’t have a alternative for measurement.
Of the 5 ice machines that I examined for this information, two weren’t as spectacular as the remainder. I’ll proceed to check the highest three ice machines over the following few months to see how they maintain up. Within the meantime, try the helpful chart beneath for the TL;DR of the successful machines’ specs. For the total outcomes, preserve studying.
1. Greatest ice machine for small areas: Frigidaire EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker
Kind of ice: Bullet
Capability: 26 kilos
This Frigidaire ice machine is tiny however mighty, and doesn’t compromise on energy. The truth is, the day by day ice manufacturing was the second highest at 26 kilos, bested by the Magic Chef model by only one pound.
The Frigidaire match beneath my pantry cupboards with room to spare, and the 12-inch depth didn’t peek out from beneath, both. Although it takes up the identical quantity of area because the Magic Chef, the massive window on high of the machine makes it look extra open and fewer cramped—a delicate however impactful design aspect that small areas profit from. It additionally enables you to see the ice being made and getting dropped into the storage bucket like prizes at an arcade.
Setup was easy—wipe down the inside, fill with filtered water, and select your ice measurement. Cleansing was a breeze, too—unplug the unit, dump ice from the bucket, and launch the stopper on the underside of the unit to let the water drain out, then wipe dry or air dry.
Like all of the machines I examined, the primary batch was admittedly not spectacular—the ice wasn’t frozen all through and melted rapidly. However just a few batches later, the small and huge sizes of ice have been completely formed and satisfying to make use of in my espresso. After about six batches of the massive ice, the basket was at its capability and the machine stopped operating till I scooped some out for my second (okay, third) cup of espresso. The bullet ice was uniform in coloration and thickness, and the cavity offered extra floor space to chill drinks down rapidly. One potential draw back with bullet ice is that it melts faster than nugget ice, however in testing, the distinction was negligible.
2. Greatest ice machine for nugget ice: GE Profile Opal 2.0 Stainless Steel Nugget Ice Maker with Side Tank
Kind of ice: Nugget
Capability: 24 kilos
Nugget ice is the popular ice form amongst our Instagram neighborhood and Fouerti—and we are able to lastly see why. The small form and uneven texture of the ice maximizes the quantity of liquid within the cup, so your drink will likely be much less diluted. For my ice chewers on the market, the scale makes it straightforward to chew with out cracking your enamel.
Organising this machine wasn’t as simple as the Frigidaire or Magic Chef because it requires you to run a cleansing cycle the primary time you employ it, so don’t anticipate to make use of this proper earlier than friends arrive. There’s additionally a self-cleaning possibility, which principally includes pushing a button and letting the machine run for some time. You can too join the unit to Wi-Fi, which is spectacular for an ice maker however for my part, unnecessarily high-tech.
Whereas GE’s Opal 2.0 was the most important I examined, it nonetheless match beneath my cupboards with out protruding. It was additionally one in every of two machines I examined that had a separate water tank, which was straightforward to fill. Sadly, the identical couldn’t be mentioned for cleansing until I used a bottle brush.
Although noticeably sleeker than the opposite fashions I examined, this was the loudest. The noise stage in my pantry when the machine wasn’t operating measured at 38 decibels based on the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health Sound Level Meter (NIOSH SLM) app, which is fairly quiet. However because the Opal 2.0 went via the ice making course of, the noise stage ranged from 55 to 62 decibels. The noise isn’t offensive or obtrusive by any means although; it’s like a barely louder fridge hum and disappears into the background after some time. But when we’re evaluating apples to apples (or is it ice to ice?), the opposite machines didn’t make any noise in any respect.
3. Greatest reasonably priced ice machine: Magic Chef 27 lbs. Portable Countertop Ice Maker
Kind of ice: Bullet
Capability: 27 kilos
The best mixture of value and worth, this Magic Chef ice maker is dependable and makes nice bullet ice in addition to another mannequin I examined, however at a barely extra reasonably priced quantity.
The preliminary setup and weekly cleansing was the identical as that of the Frigidaire, which I’d anticipated since all of the bullet ice makers I examined have been fairly related. The largest distinction is within the placement of the management panel—it’s integrated into the lid and may very well be vulnerable to breaking when you’re consistently opening and shutting the lid to scoop some ice. It’s one thing I’ll preserve an eye fixed out for as I proceed to check this machine.
With the flexibility to make as much as 27 kilos of ice in 24 hours, it boasted the most important manufacturing out of all of the bullet ice makers I examined. In actuality, it made extra like 25 kilos, however the distinction is inconsequential. After the preliminary few batches, the ice was completely formed and frozen via. Sadly, the small window on high of the machine doesn’t allow you to get a satisfying view of the ice being made and pushed into the bucket—a small compromise for the value.
What do you have to search for in countertop ice machine?
Ice manufacturing charge, storage capability, and ice form are necessary components in terms of selecting between machines, says Fouerti. The common manufacturing of my high three ice machines is about 25 kilos of ice a day and the typical storage capability is about two kilos, each of which have been greater than sufficient for my typical family of two, plus friends that came around throughout my testing interval.
What kind of ice do ice machines make?
A lot of the countertop machines I researched and examined produce bullet ice, which is the most well-liked kind of ice as a consequence of its versatility, says Fouerti. Bullet ice will at all times look cloudy or white all through as a consequence of pure minerals in water and the method of how the machine makes ice, however deBary factors out that, “Until you’re spending tons of cash on a machine, there’s no means round this, and it’s greatest to not fear an excessive amount of about it—it’s largely a beauty subject.”
In case you are planning to take a position although, nugget ice machines are rising in reputation and availability. Additionally known as pellet ice and even Sonic ice (for the reason that fast-food chain makes use of one of these ice for its drinks), this ice form is Fouerti’s most popular form as a result of it leaves quite a lot of room in your beverage even when the glass is filled with ice. “Because it takes up a lot area across the liquid, it really works very properly at retaining a cup’s contents chilly and refreshing.”
You’ll additionally see just a few machines that make cubes, although they’re much less standard and might value greater than a bullet ice maker.
How does a countertop ice machine work?
A transportable countertop ice machine works in the same option to a fridge’s built-in ice maker. There are slight variations with every mannequin, clearly, however on the whole, an ice maker has an inner cooling unit that freezes 9 rods which are dunked right into a tray of water to make particular person items of ice. As soon as the ice is prepared, the heating unit kicks in to soften the ice simply sufficient in order that it slides out of the tray or mould, after which the ice will get pushed right into a storage bucket. The machine doesn’t freeze the ice, so ice will begin to soften if it stays within the bucket too lengthy earlier than you employ it—over time, the water slowly drips down into the reservoir and will get pumped again up for the following cycle.
How do you clear an ice machine?
For the reason that mechanics of every machine differs, this relies fully on every producers’ directions. Typically although, Fouerti advises to first empty out the ice within the storage compartment and water from the tank (there’s normally a plastic drain stopper on the underside of the machine). Then dilute some vinegar or a nickel-free cleaner like Scotsman with water and wipe down the inside (you may even use the answer to make just a few cycles of ice to filter the internal mechanics of the machine!). When you’re performed cleansing, sanitize the machine and its components by operating not less than two cycles with simply water, ensuring the ice manufacturing occasions aren’t far off from regular, after which throw out the ice.
How typically do you have to clear your ice machine?
Once more, this is determined by your machine, however Fouerti suggests cleansing and sanitizing not less than as soon as each six months for effectivity. “Some machines even have an alert perform to let you understand it wants cleansing; others you will have to maintain monitor by yourself.”
What’s your favourite kind of ice? Tell us beneath!
This put up incorporates merchandise independently chosen (and liked) by our editors and writers. Food52 earns an affiliate fee on qualifying purchases of the merchandise we hyperlink to.